GuideIntroduction to Two-Stage Exams · Hyewon Jang

Two-Stage Exams2단계 평가

Solve it alone, then solve it together,
and the exam becomes learning.

A two-stage exam is a collaborative assessment: students take an exam individually, then immediately retake the same questions in small teams. Proven at Harvard and UBC and first adopted in Korea at Sejong University, it turns test day into one of the most active learning moments of the term.

Teaching in Korea? Free copies for teachers (Korean page) →

50 yearsof research since the 1970s
Harvard · UBCleading universities went first
First in Koreaadopted and studied at Sejong University
4 effectsachievement · retention · less anxiety · motivation
The tense exam room suddenly turned into a lively arena of debate. Students sketched their solutions on whiteboards and argued them out with their teammates.
Spring 2014, an introductory physics course at Harvard — from the preface of the book (translated)

01What is it

What is a two-stage exam?

A two-stage exam is an assessment in which students first complete an exam on their own (stage 1) and then, right away, solve the same exam again in small teams (stage 2). The point isn’t to test twice. The point is to turn the exam itself into another chance to learn.

STAGE 1

Individual exam

개인 평가
  • Students work alone, as in any exam.
  • It secures individual accountability: everyone prepares and answers for their own work, which prevents free-riding.
  • Suggested time: up to 50 minutes (e.g., 55 minutes in a large physics course)
STAGE 2

Team exam

팀 평가
  • Small teams solve the same questions again.
  • They explain, challenge and reach consensus on a final team answer.
  • Suggested time: 20–30 minutes (e.g., 30 minutes in a large physics course)
Final score = individual score × 85% + team score × 15%Carl Wieman’s guideline for large physics courses (Wieman et al., 2014) · 70 : 30 in the Korean case

Where does it come from? It grew out of the readiness assurance process of Team-Based Learning (TBL): an individual readiness assurance test (iRAT) followed by the same test taken as a team (tRAT) (Michaelsen et al., 2004).

Estimate a two-stage exam score

72
90
15%
74.7
Individual partTeam part

+2.7 points thanks to the team discussion

Try it

Experience a two-stage exam in one minute

  1. 1Individual
  2. 2Team
  3. 3Result

02Why now

Why two-stage exams, and why now?

Assessment should support learning. Generative AI is shaking up take-home assignments, and the future demands people who can collaborate. These three shifts meet in one place.

Purpose of assessment

Exams used to give no feedback

Traditional exams stop at measuring what individuals can do. Assessment for learning holds that assessment should drive learning. In a two-stage exam, students get feedback from peers right after the test, exactly when they are most receptive to it.

Generative AI

Take-home assessment is losing validity

When ChatGPT arrived, universities began questioning the validity of assignment-based assessment. A two-stage exam assesses people thinking together in the classroom, and researchers are now designing ways to use AI as a tool for collaboration.

Future skills

Collaboration is a core competency

The OECD Education 2030 framework emphasizes student agency and transformative competencies. Korea’s full rollout of the high school credit system (2025) and wider undeclared-major admissions bring students from different backgrounds together. Collaborative problem solving should be built into assessment itself.

OECD (2018)Korean Ministry of Education (2017)

03For you

Who benefits, and how?

From classroom teachers to policymakers, two-stage exams offer something different depending on where you stand.

One exam sheet turns class into a discussion!

FOR TEACHERS · K–12 teachers

With the same exam sheet, test time becomes your liveliest discussion time.

  • 1
    Almost no extra preparation

    Reuse the questions you already wrote in the team stage. No special equipment is needed; paper answer sheets work fine.

  • 2
    Aligned with assessment reform

    Moving beyond ranking toward assessment that supports the learning process matches the direction of student-choice curricula such as Korea’s high school credit system.

  • 3
    Quiet students speak up

    At UBC, students who were usually reserved in class participated very actively during the exam.

  • 4
    See students’ thinking first-hand

    Watching team discussions shows you, on the spot, which misconceptions exist and how students persuade one another.

  • 5
    Pre-service teachers saw it first

    Pre-service teachers who experienced a two-stage exam said it “seems easy to apply at the middle and high school level.”

In the book → Ch. III Applying it (orientation → team formation → exam design → running the exam → feedback → peer evaluation) and the appendix checklist

04Evidence

What research says about two-stage exams

From physics, chemistry, biology and sociology courses in North America to university courses in Korea, half a century of research points the same way.

↑

Achievement

Team scores are higher than individual scores, and even teams made up only of students who missed a question solved it. Students learned from each other within the team.

↑

Long-term retention

Compared with traditional exams, students who took two-stage exams retained course content longer.

↓

Test anxiety

The group score works as a safety net and discussion with peers is reassuring, so students’ perceived test anxiety dropped substantially.

↑

Motivation & experience

Solving problems together reduced study stress and made learning itself a valuable experience, raising motivation.

Better on the next individual exam

Students who took two-stage exams later scored higher on individual exams.

Bigger gains for those who need it

Effects appeared at all achievement levels, with low-performing students benefiting most, which matters for equity.

Learning, not cheating

Team-stage discussion wasn’t copying answers; it was genuinely solving problems together.

Critical thinking and valuing collaboration

In teacher education courses, students’ critical thinking improved and they came to value collaboration.

We look at the limits, too. In a large introductory biology course, collaborative testing improved immediate performance but did not significantly improve long-term retention (Leight et al., 2012). Two-stage exams may help most in courses that require conceptual reasoning and problem solving rather than rote recall, which is why question design matters.

05How it works

Why do two-stage exams work?

A two-stage exam is not just a retake. Six cognitive and social mechanisms of cooperative learning operate together inside the exam (based on 정혜선, 2019).

Resource sharing

When a friend who knows derivatives meets a friend who knows integrals, problems neither could solve alone get solved.

Constructive activity

Asking, explaining and recalling deepen understanding, especially for the student doing the explaining.

Co-construction of knowledge

Reconciling different interpretations creates new knowledge that no one could build alone.

Mutual monitoring and regulation

Other people’s mistakes are easier to spot than your own. Teammates catch and fix calculation errors.

Social facilitation

People perform better with others. Motivation and engagement rise together.

Technology support

Platforms such as Learning Catalytics and IF-AT scratch cards make automatic scoring and immediate feedback possible.

Vygotsky

Social constructivism

Knowledge first arises between people and is then internalized. Capable peers widen the zone of proximal development (ZPD).

Michaelsen

Team-Based Learning (TBL)

Individual test → team test → appeals → corrective instruction: a structure that turns groups into high-performing learning teams.

TheoryTwo-stage
exam
Johnson & Johnson

Cooperative learning

Positive interdependence, individual accountability, promotive interaction, social skills and group processing: all five elements are built into the exam.

Hutchins

Distributed cognition

A team works like one large brain. People, answer sheets, tools and AI become a single cognitive system.

Stage 1 · Individual examEach student prepares and answers alone: individual accountability
Stage 2 · Team examEveryone succeeds together: positive interdependence

06History

Fifty years of evolution: a history of two-stage exams

Rooted in social constructivism and team-based learning, two-stage exams have gone through some 50 years of empirical and methodological research and are now expanding to Asia and to AI. Click a dot or an era to see key studies with links to the originals.

Team-based learning emerged and its potential as assessment was explored. Building on Vygotsky’s social constructivism, Michaelsen’s team-based learning (iRAT → tRAT) provided the prototype of the two-stage exam, and the Johnson brothers’ cooperative learning theory served as its social and psychological engine.

1970sLarry MichaelsenTeam-Based Learning

Team-based learning emerges. Its structure, an individual readiness test (iRAT) followed by the same test as a team (tRAT), became the prototype of the two-stage exam.

Read the source ↗
1978Lev VygotskyMind in Society

Social constructivism. The idea that help from more capable peers widens the zone of proximal development became the theoretical root of collaborative assessment.

Harvard University Press (book)
1992Heller et al.Teaching problem solving through cooperative grouping

Physics education research showing that cooperative groups outperform individuals at problem solving, demonstrating the power of collaborative assessment.

Read the source ↗
1999Johnson & JohnsonMaking cooperative learning work

Five elements of cooperative learning. The individual exam creates individual accountability; the team exam creates positive interdependence.

Read the source ↗

Two-stage exams in Korea

From observations in a Harvard classroom to Korean classrooms.

  1. H2014

    Hyewon Jang studies two-stage exams as a postdoctoral fellow in Eric Mazur’s group at Harvard

  2. W2020

    Workshop at Hanyang University’s Center for Teaching and Learning on team-based assessment methods and cases

  3. S2023

    Cases from UBC, Harvard and Sejong University presented at the Korean Society for Educational Evaluation fall conference

  4. 12023.12

    First edition of the book published in Korean

  5. K2024

    First two-stage exam study of Korean undergraduates published in Sustainability

  6. 22025.1

    Revised edition published, expanding theory, history, AI chatbot cases and teamwork tips

  7. AI2025

    AI chatbot and collaborative problem-solving study “Less is more” published in New Physics: Sae Mulli

07Cases

The world started first;
Korea started at Sejong University

Leading universities, including Harvard University and the University of British Columbia (UBC) as well as MIT and Stanford, use two-stage exams.

Harvard UniversityProf. Eric Mazur
Who
The research group of physicist Eric Mazur, known for Peer Instruction
How
In introductory physics (AP50, spring 2014), an individual exam was followed by a team exam. The group built a technology platform, Learning Catalytics, for collaborative assessment, offering automatic scoring, immediate feedback and multiple attempts (4 points on the first try, 2 on the second, 1 on the third).
Why
It began from concern that traditional exam culture causes excessive stress and hinders deep learning. Students shared and debated answers until they found the correct one, and the exam room took on an atmosphere that celebrated learning itself.
Research
Balanced team formation, automatic scoring, and how team members affect team performance (Hyewon Jang, postdoctoral fellow)
University of British ColumbiaUBC · Prof. Carl Wieman
Who
Carl Wieman, 2001 Nobel laureate in physics, introduced two-stage exams while at UBC and is now a professor at Stanford University.
How
In large physics courses, a 55-minute individual exam was followed by a 30-minute group exam, with grades weighted 85 : 15, published as concrete guidelines.
What
Students who were usually quiet in class participated very actively during the exam. Starting in physics, the approach spread to many STEM fields.
Impact
It showed that the format runs reliably even in very large classes, which greatly helped it spread.
First in Korea
Sejong UniversityProf. Hyewon Jang
First
Professor Hyewon Jang was the first to use two-stage exams in Korean university courses and published the first two-stage exam study of Korean undergraduates.
Scope
Midterm and final exams in education (educational statistics, teacher-education courses) and engineering (algorithms).
Findings
Korean students experienced the same benefits as Western students (motivation, lower test anxiety), along with challenges specific to the Korean context, such as teamwork burden and concerns about losing face.
Next
Bringing generative AI chatbots into two-stage exams revealed a “less is more” effect: teams with limited AI access outperformed teams with unlimited access.
Educational statistics

40 min individual → 20 min team, team score 30%. “A chance to internalize it, whether I got it right or wrong.”

Teacher education: school violence prevention

Pre-service teachers experienced a two-stage exam first-hand. “It seems easy to apply with middle and high school students.”

Algorithms (engineering)

Teams devised algorithms that were never taught in class: the collaborative skills the software industry wants.

Five application models in the book (Ch. V)

Large lecturesSmall and mid-size classesTeam project coursesProblem-based learningTwo-stage exams with AI chatbots

08Voices

Voices from Korean classrooms

From interviews with Korean undergraduates and instructors who tried two-stage exams for the first time (Ch. VI of the book, translated).

Doing the team round right after solving it alone, I could tell whether my answer was right. It felt like working through an error notebook.
Student, teacher-education course
Seeing my own mistakes was fascinating, and that content really stuck in my head.
Student, teacher-education course
The best part was that students came up with algorithms I hadn’t taught in class.
Instructor, algorithms course
Even when I felt I hadn’t studied enough, thinking “my teammates will fill in what I missed”… helped lower my anxiety.
Student, teacher-education course
Through two-stage exams I could observe how students discuss and solve problems together.
Instructor, algorithms course
I thought it could work for a much wider range of people than ordinary team projects.
Student, teacher-education course

Challenges found in Korea

  • Teamwork burden: awkwardness with unfamiliar peers, passive teammates, difficulties for introverted students
  • Concerns about face: feeling discouraged when you immediately see that your answer was wrong
  • Time management: running out of time by debating every option
  • Sensitivity to fairness: worry that teammates’ participation affects your grade

Solutions the book proposes

  • Balanced teams: a survey covering year, gender, leadership experience, personality and major (Appendix 1)
  • Orientation and discussion practice: explain the purpose and procedure and build rapport (Appendix 3)
  • Psychological safety: rules for sharing mistakes and three sentences to use together (Appendix 4)
  • Peer evaluation: at least twice a term, with team contribution reflected in grades
“What do you think?”“I was wrong.”“Thank you for doing that.”

09FAQ

Common concerns,
answered

Everyone wonders at first!

QIsn’t a two-stage exam just allowing cheating?

No. The study “Collaborative exams: Cheating? Or learning?” showed that the team stage is genuine team problem solving, not copying, which establishes its legitimacy as assessment (Jang et al., 2017, American Journal of Physics).

QWon’t some students free-ride?

The individual first stage secures each student’s accountability. Add peer evaluation at least twice a term to reflect team contribution, with items such as “nominate the two teammates who contributed most.” Interestingly, as Korean students’ anxiety fell, their sense of responsibility to the team grew, and they prepared harder.

QWon’t team composition make scores unfair?

That’s why balanced team formation is key (Jang & Mazur, 2015). Teams are formed from a survey of gender, year, leadership experience, personality, course history, communication skills and academic background. Keeping the team weight at about 15–30% keeps grades centered on individual scores.

QIs it OK to use easy questions?

If the questions are easy, students just ask “What did you get?”, compare answers and stop. One student said, “I wish the questions gave us something to discuss.” Questions that demand higher-order thinking (analysis, synthesis, evaluation), allow multiple solution paths, and are of moderate-to-high difficulty spark real discussion.

QWon’t there be too little time?

Design the individual exam to take 50 minutes or less, and allow 20–30 minutes for the team stage. First-timers find time allocation hard, so cover discussion methods and time management in an orientation. The book’s appendix includes ready-to-use orientation materials.

QDoes it work for students used to competitive exams, as in Korea?

In a study of Korean undergraduates, students experienced the same benefits as Western students, including motivation and lower test anxiety (Jang et al., 2024). Teamwork burden and concerns about losing face also appeared, so measures that build psychological safety are needed. The book offers concrete tips.

QCan two-stage exams be run online?

Yes, but the instructors interviewed recommended in-person exams, because nonverbal communication matters when several people tackle complex problems in a short time. Collaboration-friendly rooms with round tables or movable desks help.

QCan students use AI chatbots during the team stage?

It depends on the design. Teams with restricted AI use (a shared device, or only at set times) outperformed teams with unlimited use. The more limited the access, the more strategically students discussed what and how to ask (Jang, 2025). AI is a tool and a resource, not “the answer.”

QDoes it work in K–12 schools, not just universities?

Two-stage exams have been used in engineering, the natural sciences, and the humanities and social sciences. A pre-service teacher who experienced one said, “Since it’s about explaining what you studied to others, it seems easy to apply at the middle and high school level.” It also fits assessment reform under Korea’s high school credit system.

QAre “two-stage exam,” “two-stage testing” and “collaborative exam” the same thing?

Yes, they refer to the same format. The research literature calls it a two-stage exam (or examination), two-stage testing, or a two-stage cooperative test, and more broadly classifies it as a form of collaborative (group) testing. In Korean it is called 2단계 평가 or 2단계 시험.

Cover of the revised edition of 『교사를 위한 2단계 평가 입문』 (Introduction to Two-Stage Exams)
Author
Hyewon Jang
Publisher
세스물 · revised ed., Jan 28, 2025
Pages
170
Price
₩14,500
ISBN
979-11-962668-4-4 (93370)
Language
Korean

10The book

Introduction to
Two-Stage Exams

교사를 위한 2단계 평가 입문

Written in Korean for teachers and instructors new to the method, the book introduces the two-stage exam, used in physics education to build collaborative problem-solving and learning skills. It briefly explains the concept and related theory, then covers classroom implementation, classroom research, application cases, and the experiences and perceptions of students and instructors who took part.

Teachers & instructors

A guide for anyone adopting collaborative assessment

Teacher education

A reference for courses and training on alternative assessment

EdTech developers

What to consider when designing collaborative problem-solving platforms

New in the revised edition · A period-by-period history of two-stage exam research, distributed cognition theory, a case of two-stage exams with AI chatbots, ready-to-use orientation materials, and tips for effective teamwork.

Contents Click to expand

ⅠIntroductionWhy collaborative assessment; the model and its effectsp.011+
  1. Why two-stage exams
  2. The model
  3. Future education and two-stage exams
  4. Generative AI and two-stage exams
ⅡTheoryFifty years of history, six mechanisms, four learning theoriesp.029+
  1. History of two-stage exams
  2. Cognitive and social mechanisms
  3. Theoretical background: social constructivism, team-based learning, cooperative learning, distributed cognition
ⅢApplying itA step-by-step guide you can use tomorrowp.051+
  1. Orientation
  2. Team formation
  3. Exam design
  4. Running the exam
  5. Using technology
  6. Feedback
  7. Peer evaluation
ⅣClassroom researchResearch designs and analyses to test the effectsp.083+
  1. Experimental design
  2. Assessment analysis
  3. Discourse analysis
ⅤCasesModels by class size and typep.113+
  1. Large lectures
  2. Small and mid-size classes
  3. Team project courses
  4. Problem-based learning
  5. Two-stage exams with AI chatbots
ⅥExperiences & perceptionsVoices of Korean students and instructorsp.129+
  1. Experiences and perceptions in Korea
  2. Interviews with Korean undergraduates
  3. Instructors’ experiences and perceptions
+Appendices · ReferencesField tools ready to copyp.147+
  1. Team formation survey
  2. Two-stage exam checklist
  3. Orientation materials
  4. Tips for effective teamwork: Tuckman’s five stages, psychological safety, the trust triangle, the ladder of inference, red teams, integrative decision making

From the book (translated)

Two-stage exams not only support academic achievement but also bring many strengths, including better collaborative problem solving, lower test anxiety and greater motivation.
From the preface
Considering diverse factors when forming teams is essential to maximize learning. It brings together students from different majors so they can view problems from many angles.
III. Applying it · Team formation
A two-stage exam is not simply putting students together; it is a sophisticated device that connects many minds and tools to draw out the power of thinking together.
II. Theory · Distributed cognition

Preview · Appendix 2

Two-stage exam
checklist

Check off each item as you prepare your first two-stage exam. Your progress is saved in this browser.

0 / 0 done

Pre-checkCourse context

OrientationPrepare & explain

Question designRight mix

ClassroomSupport teamwork

Exam daySmooth delivery

Peer review · feedbackReflect participation

11Author

AuthorHyewon Jang

Hyewon Jang is a professor in the Office of Educational Innovation at Sejong University in Seoul. After researching two-stage exams as a postdoctoral fellow in Eric Mazur’s group at Harvard University, Jang led research projects as a research professor at KAIST, Kyung Hee University and Korea National University of Education. At Sejong University, Jang was the first in Korea to apply and study two-stage exams in university courses.

Education policySTEM educationAI and societyHuman–AI hybrid intelligence

Books (translations and edited volumes, in Korean) 『교사를 위한 고차원적 사고력 평가의 실제』, 『핀란드 교육의 기적』, 『한국 제4차 산업혁명 연구』, 『지능정보기술 확산과 숙련 수요의 변화』 and others

12Get the book

Start two-stage exams with this book

The book is written in Korean. Order a single copy online, or email the publisher for bulk and overseas orders.

Bulk · 10+ copies

Schools & institutions

For teacher training, study groups or course textbooks, please contact the publisher directly about orders of 10 copies or more.

ssesmul@gmail.com
Email about a bulk order
Overseas · out of stock

Order by email

Outside Korea, or seeing out of stock at Kyobo or Aladin? Email the publisher and we will help you get a copy.

  • Teachers in Korea can request a free copy: see the Korean page.
Title교사를 위한 2단계 평가 입문 (개정판)
AuthorHyewon Jang
Publisher세스물
Price₩14,500
ISBN979-11-962668-4-4

Library

Further reading: key studies and resources

Black, P., & Wiliam, D. (1998). Assessment and classroom learning. Assessment in Education: Principles, Policy & Practice, 5(1), 7–74. DOI ↗

Giuliodori, M. J., Lujan, H. L., & DiCarlo, S. E. (2008). Collaborative group testing benefits high- and low-performing students. Advances in Physiology Education, 32(4), 274–278. DOI ↗

Heller, P., Keith, R., & Anderson, S. (1992). Teaching problem solving through cooperative grouping. Part 1: Group versus individual problem solving. American Journal of Physics, 60, 627–636. DOI ↗

Hutchins, E. (1995). Cognition in the Wild. MIT Press. mitpress.mit.edu ↗

Jang, H., Lasry, N., Miller, K., & Mazur, E. (2017). Collaborative exams: Cheating? Or learning? American Journal of Physics, 85(3), 223–227. DOI ↗

Jang, H., Rashid, J., & Lee, J. (2024). A qualitative study of the experiences and perceptions of Korean undergraduates regarding two-stage examinations. Sustainability, 16(18), 8273. DOI ↗

Jang, H. (2025). Less is more: A multimodal exploration of how limited AI shapes team physics problem solving. New Physics: Sae Mulli, 75(5), 449–467. DOI ↗

Jang, H., & Mazur, E. (2015). A key for team exams: Balanced teams. AAPT Summer Meeting.

Johnson, D. W., & Johnson, R. T. (1999). Making cooperative learning work. Theory Into Practice, 38(2), 67–73. DOI ↗

Lee, T. R. C., Pye, M., Lilje, O., Nguyen, H. D., Hockey, S., de Bruyn, M., & van den Berg, F. T. (2022). Two-stage examinations in STEM: A narrative literature review. International Journal of Innovation in Science and Mathematics Education, 30, 73–90. DOI ↗

Leight, H., Saunders, C., Calkins, R., & Withers, M. (2012). Collaborative testing improves performance but not content retention in a large-enrollment introductory biology class. CBE—Life Sciences Education, 11(4), 392–401. DOI ↗

Levy, D., Svoronos, T., & Klinger, M. (2023). Two-stage examinations: Can examinations be more formative experiences? Active Learning in Higher Education, 24(2), 79–94. DOI ↗

Michaelsen, L. K., Knight, A. B., & Fink, L. D. (2004). Team-Based Learning: A Transformative Use of Small Groups in College Teaching. Stylus. (Korean translation: Hakjisa, 2009) routledge.com ↗

Rempel, B. P., Dirks, M. B., & McGinitie, E. G. (2021). Two-stage testing reduces student-perceived exam anxiety in introductory chemistry. Journal of Chemical Education, 98(8), 2527–2535. DOI ↗

Rieger, G. W., & Heiner, C. E. (2014). Examinations that support collaborative learning: The students' perspective. Journal of College Science Teaching, 43(4), 41–47. DOI ↗

Shindler, J. V. (2004). "Greater than the sum of the parts?" Examining the soundness of collaborative exams in teacher education courses. Innovative Higher Education, 28, 273–283. DOI ↗

Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes. Harvard University Press.

Wieman, C. E., Rieger, G. W., & Heiner, C. E. (2014). Physics exams that promote collaborative learning. The Physics Teacher, 52(1), 51–53. DOI ↗

Zipp, J. F. (2007). Learning by exams: The impact of two-stage cooperative tests. Teaching Sociology, 35(1), 62–76. DOI ↗

UBC Faculty of Science (2018). Two Stage Midterm Exam for Large Class [Video]. youtube.com ↗

Carl Wieman Science Education Initiative (2014). Two-Stage Exams [Instructor guide, PDF]. cwsei.ubc.ca ↗

Harvard Graduate School of Education, Instructional Moves. Creating assessments with individual and collaborative components. instructionalmoves.gse.harvard.edu ↗

Mazur, E. (2017). The pedagogy behind Learning Catalytics [Presentation]. mazur.harvard.edu ↗

장혜원, 민경석, Junaid Rashid (2023). 2단계 평가 적용 방안과 사례: UBC, 하버드, 세종대 사례를 중심으로 [Applying two-stage exams: cases from UBC, Harvard and Sejong University]. 한국교육평가학회 추계학술대회 [Korean Society for Educational Evaluation fall conference].